Saturday, 13 November 2010

Feedback

As previously mentioned, we were able to get feedback sheets from our peers about what they thought of our pitch for our music video. The things that they were asked to comment on were :
  • Comments on the suitability for stated target audience
  • Comments on originality of the idea
  • Comments and thoughts of logistical arrangements
  • Comments on the technical aspects - does it sound achieveable with the college equipment?
  • Does this idea sound exciting, realistic and achieveable?
I will be writing the positive and the negative feedback that I recieve from my classmates.

Comments of the suitability for stated target audience
We stated in our pitch that our audience would be white females, aged 14-17. We also explained that we believed that there would be a secondary audience, this being males aged 15-20 with both of the audiences being C2/D on the jicnar scale. A lot of people reacted positively to how we talked about our audience. One person said 'They got the audience spot on.' Another person said 'Very suitable, the moodboard made it a lot clearer.' The fact that the audience brought up the moodboard as being one of the indicators that helped identify our target audience is really reassuring, and makes me feel like we've gone in the right direction with our audience and music video.

Even though we got quite a few positive comments about our audience some people didn't understand. One person said 'Aimed at men only, where I feel women will enjoy it too.' Me and Stacey both clearly stated that we would have two audiences, one that the song is aimed at, and one that the video is aimed at. We feel that both sexes would enjoy this video for many different reasons. Another person also said 'It could have been explained a lot better.' I do believe that if me and Stacey had run through our pitch a few times we would have been able to plan what we were going to say and how we were going to say it in much more detail than we did.

Comments on origniality of the idea
Unlike the previous question, the majority of our class-mates had positive comments on the originality of our ideas. Me and Stacey believed that our video idea had some redundant ideas as well as some entropic ones. A lot of people agreed with us. 'Quite original, but has been used before.' I believe that this is completely true. We gave examples of current music videos out there that use pin up ideas like ours, However, Stacey and I both stated that we wanted to try and make the music video professional and contemporary.

On the other hand, some people said that they were 'Not sure if the idea could gel with the genre.' This could be seen as a negative comment, however, I believe that because the song doesn't necessarily flow as easily as for example a dance video would, this makes the idea a lot more entropic and amplifying, as we have listened to the lyrics and interpreted them differently from the normal redundant pop video. But, a lot of othe people had the same idea as us and thought that 'it will make an orignial video,' as it is quite an entropic idea.

Comments and thoughts on the logistical arrangements
As me and Stacey haven't yet finalised a studio for our music video, this was probably the most vague part of our pitch. We did say that we would do it in a studio setting and Stacey briefly mentioned that she has a studio at her workplace. However, we didn't state how we would get there. One person said 'Arrangements don't seem well thoughout.' This is something both Stacey and I are working on as we believe that it is essential to be organised during this long project.

We also mentioned in our pitch that we would like to include about 8-10 girls in our music video. Many people thought this would be a problem logistically, 'Organisation could be hard with 8-10 people.' Another person said 'Transport for 8 people?' This is also something we need to try and think about. We decided that we would probably not take all 8-10 people at the same time, but we would shoot them individually. If we mentioned this in our pitch I believe that a lot of people would be less confused about the logistics of the project.

On the other hand we also had a few positive comments about the studio idea 'Studio is a good idea.' 'Use of photographers studio is really good.' We both agree that the photography studio is a good idea as it will keep to the clean simple theme of our video, now we just need to try and find somewhere to actually shoot the video in January.

Comments on the technical aspects of the idea - Does it sound achieveable with college equipment?
Both Stacey and myself are quite confident when it comes to certain aspects of college equipment. Stacey has some experience in shooting with a video camera, and I have some experience when it comes to post production and editing. However, we have both decided that we both need to try and practise a few times to make sure we become more confident in both sides of production as we would both like to try shooting and editing. We have also decided that we would like to add animaton to our music video. One person said 'It's going to be mad, but achieveable if they work really hard.' I couldn't agree more with them. If we practise and have a go at using all of the different software that we have at college, I believe mine and Stacey's finished music video will look quite professional and interesting which is what we are aiming for.

Does this idea sound exciting, realistic and achieveable?
The majority of our peers all seem very excited about the video that me and Stacey are going to create. We both know that it is going to be quite challenging, especially in post-production, but if we work hard we should be able to create something really unique.

Someone said 'Sounds like an interesting and different idea, but the amount of people involved and the image techniques might make things difficult and hard to achieve.' I believe that this is quite true. It will take lots of time and lots of effort to try and achieve the music video that we are heading for, however, me and Stacey are very dedicated and are willing to take up a challenge and work hard in production and post-production of our work. If me and Stacey work really hard I believe we can achieve the video that we are planning.

No comments:

Post a Comment