Entropy - '...is unpredictability'
For the start of my media research, I had to look into 4 music videos and find out what made them entropic, and what made them redundant. For my first video, I chose to write about Lady GaGa's song Alejandro.
- In the first scene we see a man with a police hat on wearing fishnet stockings and high heels. This isn’t something we would expect. The fact that he’s surrounded by guns is a contrast, and quite grungy and dark compared to what you would expect from a pop video.
- Unusual dancing. Military themed. Very structured and purposeful. Goes with the video, but not with the song. Mainly the backing dancers are dancing. All male dancers bar Lady Gaga.
- Religion is referenced in the video, and we rarely get this. For example the Jewish symbol of the Star of David is being held by the military. Could references to the Holocaust. We don’t expect this in a pop video; it’s irrelevant to pop music in general. Also the nun outfit could also be a reference.
- We expect her to wear sexier underwear like in her other videos, however, in this one she is wearing a very dull, nude coloured bra and knickers, which you don’t expect, as they are not flattering.
- Opening of a funeral before the song is quite grim and you don’t expect this at the start of your usual pop video. It’s quite dark and graphic.
- Images and montages of a war are in the background which you don’t expect; this could also reinforce the Holocaust idea.
- We would normally expect sexual references in her videos, but this one is quite explicit due to the sexual nature and nudity within the video.
· You expect sexuality in Lady Gaga’s videos and pop videos in general. Also the role reversal in the video is something Lady Gaga is known for. She comes across as quite masculine, for example when she is smoking the pipe and she controls the men, e.g. by string. And when she watches them dance.
- We expect dancing, where everyone is doing the same, we get this in this video
- We expect the artist to wear eccentric outfits, however they do seem very bland and dull compared with her other work.References to other artists, e.g. Madonna.
- Basic video structure which you would expect as she likes to tell a story in her videos, and we expect this.
- We expect a variety and advanced editing, for example flashbacks in black and white.
For my next video, I decided to analyse a very simple and yet effective video. I chose OK Go - Here it goes again. With my friend, we went through the video in great detail and picked out what we came to believe was entropic, and what we thought was redundant about the OK Go video.
Entropic
- One continuous frame is used so which is unusual because we would expect more high tech videos and editing due to the technology available.
- The appearance of the band, geeks dancing on treadmills. The two ideas should not work, but in this case, it's endearing.
- Low budget, redundant music video but this makes it entropic, as it is simple but effective and entertaining.
- The set up, not clear where it is set as it is a basic background with six tread mills so that fact that this is kept from the audience makes it entropic as people are left to think and imagine where they could be filming this.
- Artistic and simplistic as everything is executed almost perfectly, when watching you cannot take your eyes of the video this is why it has become such a huge hit on Youtube
The appearance of the set up of the video seems to be produced by an amateur e.g. before the music starts the band manually turn the music on with a controller which is different compared to videos such as; Alejandro. This seems to be redundant video but it translates as quite an entropic video due the simplicity and layout.
Redundant
- Does relate to the song which most music videos do not.
- Dancing and singing, the dancing seems easy, but the fact that it's on treadmills and is one continuous dance routine creates an entropic tone to the music video.
- Focus on the band, which most music videos tend to do, by doing this it gives the band a certain image, in this case ; simple and a bit geeky.
- Easy to copy as it is so simple.
- The use of the treadmills could be seen as some sort of advertising.
- As it is a low budget video, titling is used to introduce the song, this looks and seems quite cheap and very simple.
For the next music video which I research, I looked at Laura Marling's song New Romantic. I had always been intrigued by this video and thought that it would be a good idea to analyse it and see what was Entropic about it, and what was Redundant.
Entropic
- Use of shadows on the wall behind the artist is quite entropic and you don't really see it in a normal music video. It gives quite a good, interesting effect. Shadows go over the artists' face which is quite unusual because most videos are created to make the artist look good, in this case the shadows are blocking her face. Also a shadow of a close up of her playing guitar, this is very unusual and gives a nice different appeal to the video.
- Extremely simple video, which could give the idea of redundancy , but because it is so simple, just in a warehouse, hardly any light, only one that is used for shadow emphasis, this could come across as entropic because it is utterly just so simple, whereas nowadays you would expect something a bit more over the top and high tech.
- The artist isn't at all sexualised in the video, which we expect from any other video. In fact she is wearing a long trousers and a high neck top, we normally would see more skin from a female artist.
- She is sat down for almost the entire of the video. There is only one shot where she is standing.
- No dancing in the video, as she is sat down playing the guitar throughout.
Redundant
- Very simple style of video, seems quite amateur at times.
- She's sat on a stool, which is featured in a lot of videos where the artists is performing. She's also playing a guitar which could also tie into the performance feel of the video, this is very redundant when it comes to music video styles.
- Lots of repeated shot types and editing. This could get quite boring and predictable as you see some of the shots at least 2-3 times.
- Close up shots of artist, very redundant and extremely expected in a music video.
For my final video, I decided to research My Chemical Romance's song, Helena. This video has always stuck with me as it is quite unusual and bizarre for a music video. Like the others, I have yet again analysed this video on its entropy and redundancy.
Entropic
- The fact that churches are a place of peace and worship it contrasts with the loud rock ‘mosh’ music, the two should not work but the fact that they do is entropic.
- The expressive, ballet dancing in this music video is also something we would not expect from the ‘emo’ genre, in fact we wouldn’t expect dancing at all. Once again two things that should not work together do, in this case the dancing is the highlight of the video which makes the idea entropic.
- The fact that a band member is taking on the persona of the priest is also bizarre, the fact that they’ve got this gothic, satanic image about them contrasts with the environment which they are in.
- Other people sing along to the song in a religious manner, for example if they were singing a hymn.
- There are the American traditions of having an open-coffin, but this could also be interpreted as entropy as it is quite graphic.
- The video is a bit grim and emotional, and the emotions put across by the artist are genuine, which is unusual because most artists don’t connect with their song in such a manner.
- The solo-dance in a ballet style is very peculiar in contrast with the genre. But at the same time it kind of works with the theme of the song and image of the video. We have already been introduced to the dancing previously in the video, but in this case it is entropic as the girl is dead but she dancing, this creates a twist with the story as this seems to be a fantasy sequence.
Redundant
- The gothic elements and tone to the video are predictable and reflects the band, who are quite dark. The colours black and reds which are associated with the goth genres are present e.g. the clothing and the set.
- The set and location is not too surprising to us as we expect it from the artist as well as the genre e.g. lit candles and set in a gothic environment, in this case a church.
- The costumes worn by both the band and extras are predictable as they are wearing gothic black suits with red accessorises e.g. tie. The image of the band reflects the gothic ‘emo’ genre so the black hair and men wearing makeup is not too surprising and is quite redundant. The women in this video are dressed erotically e.g. short gothic tutu dresses, we expect this from a music video of the genre ‘emo’ to attract both the male and female gaze.
- The band perform and rock out which you expect to see in any music video, this predictable and redundant.
- Repetitive ideas and camera shots, e.g. standing up and sitting down along with the music, mainly through the chorus
- Pathetic Fallacy is present in this video near the end, rain is used to symbolise the sadness of the artist, this looks visually spectacular and creates emotion but this is redundant as many videos create illustrated videos.